Tuesday, November 19, 2013

The Monroe Doctrine Is Not Dead

Secretary of State Kerry gave a speech saying the Monroe Doctrine was over, by which he meant it is currently fashionable to speak in non-interventionist terms while retaining the prerogative to intervene. As long as security remains a critical part of U.S. foreign policy, then some version of the Monroe Doctrine will persist.

We can, however, publicly pretend it is not there. From the speech:

Each year, hundreds of thousands of Americans visit Havana, and hundreds of millions of dollars in trade and remittances flow from the United States to Cuba. We are committed to this human interchange, and in the United States we believe that our people are actually our best ambassadors. They are ambassadors of our ideals, of our values, of our beliefs.

I wonder what the response was in the room as he said this? The United States is committed to the precise opposite of what he claims. If the U.S. did not consider itself a hemispheric police officer, to paraphrase Teddy Roosevelt's interpretation of the Monroe Doctrine, then why would it actively block travel to Cuba, as it does now?

There's lots of nice stuff about cooperation in the speech, which is good, but it is not the same as truly rejecting unilateral action on behalf of U.S. interests, often phrased in terms of what the offending party is doing wrong. The U.S. does so a lot, though admittedly not as much as in TR's time, when imperialism was seen as a good thing.

We're in a funny time where both the left in Latin America and the U.S. government keep saying the hegemonic period of the United States is done. And they're both wrong. True, the U.S. does not invade the same way it used to, but the unilateral use of power--either overtly or behind the scenes--is far from gone. The U.S. is doing so on a constant basis, and not just in Cuba. The U.S. has far more power than any Latin American country, in virtually any sense of the term, and it consistently uses that power. If anything, we should be very surprised if it didn't. It is important to note as well that choosing not to use that power all the time is not a sign of the doctrine's demise. Even in the its heydays of intervention the U.S. selectively decided when to invoke it, sometimes to the frustration of Latin American leaders who wanted it.

In a way, this has become an intellectual game. The Monroe Doctrine was proclaimed dead not too long after it was pronounced. In 1863, someone even felt obliged to write a book refuting the idea that the Monroe Doctrine had died.  In the 1930s it was common for even prominent U.S. politicians to say the doctrine was dead. Khrushchev declared the doctrine to be dead in 1960. Historian Gaddis Smith said it died at the end of the Cold War. As he was dying in 2011, Hugo Chávez said it was dead. And now John Kerry.


Defensores de Democracia 3:12 PM  

Obama hosts the best friend of TERRORISTS on December 3 : Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos wants to appoint many of FARC Narcos and Kidnappers to the Colombian Congress : They are murderers of Children, Women and the Old, with land Mines, Bombs that kill innocent civilians in Populated Towns, and throwing explosive gas cylinders on the poorest villagers and peasants

You can not conceive worse War Criminals. It is like if the Allies had appointed the Nazi Criminals to the Bundestag of Germany in 1945, without fair elections.

Is it beautiful that the President of the USA hosts and praises such "Statesman" of cowardice, weakness, dishonor, indignity, degradation. ??

Isn't Obama polluted and contaminated by the bad traits of Santos ??

Santos lives in a political Disneyland of Fantasies, Delusions, Vanity and Narcissism. He gives Heaven and Earth to the Criminals that Kidnap, cash the ransom and murder the hostage. But he attacks with verbal violence, insults and bellicosity those that do not share his delusions of grandeur.

For more than 60 years FARC has constantly deceived the public with false attempts of Peace. They are the kingdom of Lies, Hypocrisy, Fallaciousness, Deception, Chicanery, Trickery.

So Santos is a fool or a very wicked man. How many innocent people do you have to kill in order to be a member of the Colombian Congress ?? And you get a free pass by the Fraud and Scam of the "Special circumscriptions", those are Fake Districts where the Criminal and Murderer has no competitors because he can kill all the rivals.

This is an election with a gun in your head.

Is Obama going to praise and toast Santos ?? - A man so flawed as to deliver his country tied from feet and hands to Narco Terrorists

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP